Tiger King and the fail-tastic baking abominations on Nailed It!, the start of the COVID pandemic left reality TV viewers with many guilty pleasures to choose from.

So many, in fact, that you may have missed the one show from that time that dared to go where no reality TV show had gone before, by including a masturbation competition in its very first episode.Labor of Love made us wonder if the straights were okay all over again by featuring Kristy Katzmann, a 41-year-old bachelorette who got to choose which of 15 men would win her heart and the honor of impregnating her.Accompanied by Sex and the City‘s Kristin Davis, Katzmann greeted the men in the show’s May 2020 premiere episode.

Waiters then handed each man a cup, and Katzmann announced that she wanted a sperm sample from each one to prove that they could actually be fathers.“I did not see this coming, no pun intended,” said one of the competitors, Matt Kaye.It may seem a bit premature to ask a guy to fill a cuppy on the first date, but Katzmann’s biological clock is ticking and she wants a bun in the oven — hey, no judgments, gurl!